Post-Publication Discussion

Post-Publication Discussion

JECCE (Journal of Early Childhood Care and Education) encourages constructive, evidence-based scholarly discussion of articles published in the journal. Post-publication discussion provides an opportunity for readers, researchers, and authors to clarify, critically evaluate, and discuss published findings, thereby contributing to scientific progress and maintaining the integrity of the scholarly record.

Submission of Comments and Concerns

Readers and researchers may submit comments, scholarly critiques, questions, or concerns regarding published articles through the journal’s official editorial email address. Submissions should be relevant to the published work, supported by appropriate evidence where applicable, and written in a professional and respectful manner.

Editorial Assessment and Author Response

All submissions are assessed by the Editor-in-Chief or a designated editor for scholarly relevance, accuracy, originality, and compliance with publication ethics standards. Where appropriate, the original author(s) may be invited to respond to substantive comments or criticisms. The journal may request supporting evidence or subject submissions to further editorial assessment or peer review before deciding whether they should be published.

The journal does not consider comments that contain personal attacks, defamatory statements, discriminatory language, unsupported allegations, or material unrelated to the scholarly content of the article.

Research Integrity Concerns

If a post-publication discussion raises concerns regarding possible errors, research misconduct, or the reliability of a published article, the journal will assess the matter in accordance with its publication ethics policies and relevant Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) guidance. Depending on the findings, appropriate action may include publishing a correction, an expression of concern, a retraction, or another relevant editorial notice.

Transparency and Fairness

Post-publication discussions are handled fairly, objectively, and as promptly as reasonably possible. Relevant parties are given an appropriate opportunity to respond, and editorial decisions are made independently based on scholarly merit, available evidence, and publication ethics considerations.

The journal’s procedures are informed by COPE guidance on post-publication critiques and the principles of transparency and best practice in scholarly publishing.

Official references must be included

  1. COPE Flowchart: Handling of Post-Publication Critiques - Workflow guide for handling criticism of published articles.

  2. Principles of Transparency and Best Practice in Scholarly Publishing - The principle of transparency, which encompasses policies regarding post-publication discussion.

  3. ICMJE Recommendations: Correspondence - Additional guidelines for the reader comment mechanism, author responses, and the screening of comments by editors