Analisis Filosofis terhadap Putusan Rangkap Jabatan Mahkamah Konstitusi dalam Perspektif Utilitarianisme

Authors

  • Qodriyah Isniyati Fakultas Hukum, Universitas Muhammadiyah Yogyakarta, Indonesia
  • Trisno Raharjo Fakultas Hukum, Universitas Muhammadiyah Yogyakarta, Indonesia
  • Yeni Widowaty Fakultas Hukum, Universitas Muhammadiyah Yogyakarta, Indonesia

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.12928/adlp.v6i1.15941

Keywords:

Hukum, Keadilan, Konstitusionalisme, Progresif, Utilitarianisme

Abstract

Penelitian ini bertujuan untuk menganalisis Putusan Mahkamah Konstitusi Nomor 128/PUU-XXIII/2025 melalui perspektif utilitarian guna mengkaji bagaimana penalaran berbasis konsekuensi beroperasi dalam pengujian konstitusional di Indonesia. Putusan ini muncul dari celah normatif dalam Pasal 23 Undang-Undang Nomor 39 Tahun 2008 tentang Kementerian Negara, yang secara eksplisit melarang Menteri, tetapi tidak melarang Wakil Menteri, untuk merangkap jabatan. Kekosongan hukum ini menimbulkan kekhawatiran serius terkait konflik kepentingan, profesionalitas pemerintahan, dan kepercayaan publik terhadap penyelenggaraan negara. Urgensi penelitian ini terletak pada kecenderungan Mahkamah Konstitusi yang semakin sering menggunakan pertimbangan pragmatis dan berorientasi konsekuensi, khususnya melalui penggunaan inkonstitusionalitas bersyarat dan penundaan pemberlakuan putusan. Dengan menggunakan metode yuridis-filosofis melalui pendekatan kualitatif normatif, studi ini melakukan analisis filosofis hukum berdasarkan teori utilitarian, analisis konseptual mengenai kepentingan publik dan tata kelola pemerintahan yang baik, serta analisis berbasis kasus terhadap ratio decidendi Mahkamah. Temuan penelitian menunjukkan bahwa Mahkamah secara implisit mengadopsi pendekatan utilitarianisme aturan dengan mengutamakan manfaat kolektif jangka panjang di atas legalitas tekstual, namun di saat yang bersamaan memunculkan ketegangan konstitusional terkait kepastian hukum, perlindungan hak, dan supremasi konstitusi. Penelitian ini menyimpulkan bahwa penalaran utilitarian dapat berfungsi sebagai alat bantu interpretasi dalam pengujian konstitusional, namun harus tetap dibatasi oleh batasan normatif yang jelas guna menjaga moralitas konstitusi dan keadilan substantif.

References

Aisyah, S., & Wulandari, D. F. (2025). Analysis of the Principle of Utilitarianism in Judicial Decision-Making: A Study of Constitutional Court Decision Number 135/PUU-XXII/2024 Regarding the Separation of National and Regional Elections. Judge : Jurnal Hukum, 6(04), 877–891. https://doi.org/10.54209/judge.v6i04.1780

Cheong, B. C. (2025). Bending the Arc of Law: Positivism Meets Climate Change’s Intergenerational Challenge. Transnational Environmental Law, 14(2), 285–311. https://doi.org/10.1017/S2047102525000032

Cleary, M. R., & Öztürk, A. (2022). When Does Backsliding Lead to Breakdown? Uncertainty and Opposition Strategies in Democracies at Risk. Perspectives on Politics, 20(1), 205–221. https://doi.org/10.1017/S1537592720003667

Daga, H., Kaushik, H., Choudhary, L., & Alam, T. (2025). Balancing the see-saw of morality and law—An approach to analyze the contours of morality exclusion of patenting under the Indian Patent Law. The Journal of World Intellectual Property, 28(3), 726–744. https://doi.org/10.1111/jwip.12351

Dupret, B., & Blouët, A. (2025). Dissent as a Formal Feature of Rule by Law: A Textual Legal Ethnography of Adjudication in Authoritarian Contexts. https://doi.org/10.1163/15730255-bja10179

Fathi, M., Riyanto, A. A. P., Prasetyoningsih, N., & Amirullah, M. N. R. (2025). From Guardians to Threats? Abusive Judicial Review and Public Distrust. Jurnal Hukum IUS QUIA IUSTUM, 32(2), 505–527. https://doi.org/10.20885/iustum.vol32.iss2.art10

Fathi, M., & Tripathi, A. (2025). Presidential Term Limit as an Implicit Unamendable Provision In Indonesia’s Hyper-Presidentialism. Constitutionale, 6(2), 79–94. https://doi.org/10.25041/constitutionale.v6i2.4524

Ferraro, F. (2022a). Utility, Predictability, and Rights: Bentham’s Utilitarianism and Constitutional Entitlements. Ratio Juris, 35(1), 38–54. https://doi.org/10.1111/raju.12335

Ferraro, F. (2022b). Utility, Predictability, and Rights: Bentham’s Utilitarianism and Constitutional Entitlements. Ratio Juris, 35(1), 38–54. https://doi.org/10.1111/raju.12335

Ferraro, F. (2024). Chapter 7: Utilitarian legal procedures. https://www.elgaronline.com/edcollchap/book/9781789901726/book-part-9781789901726-12.xml

Hasani, E., & Korenica, F. (2023). “Two Courts” for One Constitution: Fragmentation of Constitutional Review in the Law of the Kosovo Specialist Chambers in The Hague. German Law Journal, 24(2), 385–401. https://doi.org/10.1017/glj.2023.4

Herlindah, & Darmawan, Y. (2022). Development Legal Theory and Progressive Legal Theory: A Review, In Indonesia’s Contemporary Legal Reform. Peradaban Journal of Law and Society, 1(1). https://doi.org/10.59001/pjls.v1i1.22

Kohavi, T. (2025). The normative structure of constitutional rights: The expansionist trend and the spectre of utilitarianism. Jurisprudence, 16(1), 101–123. https://doi.org/10.1080/20403313.2024.2369418

Kurnia, T. S., Darumurti, K. D., & Moonik, P. K. (2025). Indonesian Constitutional Court’s Moral Legitimacy: A Dworkinian Rights-Based Defense. PADJADJARAN JURNAL ILMU HUKUM (JOURNAL OF LAW), 12(1), 48–68.

Kurniawan, I. G. A. (2022). Putusan Mahkamah Konstitusi Terhadap Undang-Undang Cipta Kerja Dalam Perspektif Filsafat Utilitarianisme. JURNAL USM LAW REVIEW, 5(1), 282–298. https://doi.org/10.26623/julr.v5i1.4941

Lubis, A. R., & Azhami, M. R. N. (2025). Beyond the “Greatest Happiness Principle”: Exploring the Compatibility of Individual Rights and Utilitarian Ethics in Legal Policy Making. Enigma in Law, 3(1), 1–13. https://doi.org/10.61996/law.v3i1.78

Mumcu, A. Y. (2024). Exploring the intersection of utilitarianism and sustainability in business: A conceptual analysis. Economics, Management and Sustainability, 9(1), 119–131.

Nwokora, Z. (2022). Constitutional design for dynamic democracies: A framework for analysis. International Journal of Constitutional Law, 20(2), 580–610. https://doi.org/10.1093/icon/moac030

Pratiwi, E., Negoro, T., & Haykal, H. (2022). Teori Utilitarianisme Jeremy Bentham: Tujuan Hukum Atau Metode Pengujian Produk Hukum? Jurnal Konstitusi, 19(2), 268–293. https://doi.org/10.31078/jk1922

Raadschelders, J. C. N., & Sanders, H. R. P. (2025). New development: Loyalty to principle or politics—The US civil service under attack … but is it justified? Public Money & Management, 45(2), 144–150. https://doi.org/10.1080/09540962.2024.2376373

Regier, C. (2024). Labour Law, Employees’ Capability for Voice, and Wellbeing: A Framework for Evaluation. Journal of Human Development and Capabilities, 25(1), 87–109. https://doi.org/10.1080/19452829.2023.2266691

Rizkika, K. (2024). Juridicial Review of the Appointment of An Ex-Convict of Corruption to Be A Commissioner of Bumn and Subsidiary Company of Bumn and Its Implication for Good Corporate Governance (Gcg. Eduvest - Journal of Universal Studies, 4(6), 5367–5351. https://doi.org/10.59188/eduvest.v4i6.1479

Singh, D. D. (2025). The Ethics of Law: Understanding Legal Norms Through the Lens of Humanistic Thought. International Journal of Humanities & Legal Research, 37–59.

Stivers, C., Pandey, S. K., DeHart-Davis, L., Hall, J. L., Newcomer, K., Portillo, S., Sabharwal, M., Strader, E., & Wright II, J. (2023). Beyond social equity: Talking social justice in public administration. Public Administration Review, 83(2), 229–240. https://doi.org/10.1111/puar.13620

Tommasini, N. (2024). Judicial self-empowerment and unconstitutional constitutional amendments. International Journal of Constitutional Law, 22(1), 161–190. https://doi.org/10.1093/icon/moae009

Yang Jikai. (2024). Discussion on Utilitarianism and Rights. Academic Journal of Humanities & Social Sciences, 7(6). https://doi.org/10.25236/AJHSS.2024.070605

Yeates, M. (2024). Counterfactual Utilitarianism: A New Metaphysical Framework for Consequentialist Ethics. https://uen.pressbooks.pub/range25i1/chapter/yeates/

Yusrizal, N., & Nuraini, R. (2025). The Abolition Of The Presidential Threshold From The Perspective Of Fikih Siyasah (A Study Of Constitutional Court Decision No. 62/Puu-Xxii/2024). Hukum Islam, 25(1), 103–116. https://doi.org/10.24014/hi.v25i1.36672

Zhai, X. (2024). Chapter 5: Jeremy Bentham, J.S. Mill and the utilitarian constitution. https://www.elgaronline.com/edcollchap/book/9781789901726/book-part-9781789901726-10.xml

Downloads

Published

2026-10-30

Issue

Section

Articles